Now two seemingly unrelated topics that we spoke about :
My cousin who seemed to be waiting for this told us that she (the kid) was very upset that day because of what happened at school. Apparently that morning after the first period, my niece felt uncomfortable wearing her shoes and removed it. She stuffed it in her bag and was going around in her socks. Her class teacher who taught English, noticed this and asked her where her shoes were and this girl said that she had not worn shoes to school that day. The teacher admonished her for this, wrote a note for the parents in the kid’s diary - things seem normal till this point. What she did next is strange - she complained about this to the principal, who then called my cousin and her husband to complain. Since she (the principal) was able to reach only my cousin’s husband, she started yelling at him for sending the kid to school without her shoes and for being an irresponsible parent. My brother-in-law was annoyed and at first protested saying that he was sure the girl had worn her shoes to school and on learning that it was the school’s principal who was yelling, controlled his temper and promised to be more careful.
As all good fathers do, he later chided my cousin for being careless. My cousin asked my niece why she had hidden her shoes and later lied to the teacher. The girl was in tears. My cousin gently told her that no matter what, lying was a bad thing.
As we were talking about this, she mentioned something else. In the recent exams, my niece had scored over 90 in Maths and Social Sciences and over 60 in other subjects except English where she had scored a paltry 45. This was strange, to say the least. She also recounted her recent experience in the PTA meeting at school, where the same teacher complained to my cousin in front of the other parents that my niece had torn a page off her English textbook and that as punishment her teacher had refused to return the book to her.
This happened in one of the most popular schools in Chennai. Although all of us felt that the teacher and the principal had behaved irrationally, for the sake of the kid, I advised my cousin to have a heart-to-heart chat with the teacher and see if things could be resolved amicably.
While I thought that my niece was wrong in lying to the teacher about her shoes, I also realized that all these problems probably had a common root. My niece seemed to be afraid of this teacher and that probably caused her to lose interest in the subject too.
Does this seem familiar to any of you? Most of us have had experiences with a certain teacher who hated us for no reason. I have seen a few in my school days. They would pick on one particular student and constantly tease him/her, insult the student, even destroy their morale sometimes. More often than not, the student ends up hating the subject in retaliation. In my case, my nemesis in school was a sports teacher. He hated the fact that I existed and tried to hurt me whenever possible. This probably explains my total lack of interest in any kind of sports. My aunt who was a teacher has even told me that one of her colleagues who often used to target a certain student in her class, confessed that she hated the sight of him and had no idea why.
The thought that the unreasonable hatred or dislike of a certain person can turn a 6 year old towards lying, to temporarily escape from the teacher’s wrath (as she probably thought that her teacher would blame the parents instead) and also develop a hatred towards a certain subject, deeply saddened me. My mother still cannot forget the taunts of a certain science teacher in school, due to whom, she lost all interest in the subject that year and consequently scored badly in that subject alone - an event that subsequently changed the course of her life.
Due to some unavoidable circumstances, my niece has to spend an hour or two all by herself at home in the evenings, since both her parents work and my aunt who usually takes care of the kid, is away from Chennai for a short while. I was telling my cousin to ask her to keep the door locked and not open the door for strangers. Although I was afraid to voice my fears, I told my cousin to be very careful with the kid and to warn her about lurking dangers around her. My cousin was telling me later that she was trying to tell the kid about good and bad touches from different people and that she had explicitly instructed her to report any mischief by others immediately. I was reminded of my music teacher in school, who would call the girls in the class to her room and ask us to be careful with the Art teacher. She would ask a few girls if he had touched them. I remember finding it disgusting then thinking that this lady was trying to take away our innocence and was corrupting our minds. Now I think she was only trying to look out for us, probably because she had seen and/or suspected something afoul. It was a government school and the politics played there are worse than the politics we see in our organization. The best she could do was to warn us in vague terms to be ‘careful’.
I was thinking about these things again and again yesterday night and in the morning. What kind of our world are our kids growing up in? I have just returned from a visit to my niece and nephew in Singapore and the thought that these perfect beings will grow progressively less innocent and more imperfect in order to survive in this world sends shivers down my spine. I would not want them to learn what bias means or what hatred means. I would not want them to know that in the real world, there are sheep and there are wolves in sheep’s clothing and externally they appear the same. But then how will they survive in this world? In the first incident, more than the teacher’s behaviour, I was deeply disturbed by the fact that the 6 year old kid could sense the teacher’s dislike and proceeded to lie over a small thing. I can see her gradually moving from the innocence of childhood to the deceits of adulthood. In the latter case, much as I would want her to trust every person she meets, the fact that I am seeing more and more reports on child molestation - with the minimum age limit of the victim going down every day- I am wondering if losing her innocence is the price to pay for her safety.
We lost our innocence too, but the age of losing our innocence seems to be going down of late. Kids are forced out of their innocence and childhood by the deluge of infotainment in the media, an overdose of sex and violence everywhere. Nothing seems to entertain or satisfy and the craving for more of everything seems to be the order of the day. While I look on, the children are oblivious to what they are missing. So is it a trade-off between innocence and survival? There are no easy answers. Meanwhile I feel really old and tired already.